Are firepits good heaters?

The Wizard • February 21, 2023

This is a subtitle for your new post

The short answer would be no.  They're really decorative items, and in my view shouldn't be considered space heaters.  The basic reason for this is that all the hot air is going straight up.  So the convection flow is against you.  You're getting some radiant heat, but it's spreading out in all directions.  A typical Home Depot style fire pit is something like 30k - 50k BTU, which is going to heat up the front of you within something like a 5-6' radius circle around the fire pit.  Not great considering you'll be paying around $2.50 an hour if you're on propane.  (8-10 hours per tank, around $20.00 - $25.00 to fill up that bottle with current prices).  The dollar equation gets a bit better if you're on natural gas, which you'll want to be for most firepits with larger burners.  They can run 200,000 BTU plus on a large or custom fire pit.  And when you go up to that kind of burner, you'd like to think you get significantly more heated area, but alas.  I'd really like to do some testing on this, but my experience tells me that even a 200,000 BTU burner won't radiate heat more than about 6', giving a roughly 12' circle of radiant heat.  One therm of natural gas is up to about $1.80 nationwide, and a therm contains roughly 100,000 BTU.  So our 200k btu fire pit would cost us $3.60 per hour to run. 


The alternative?  Particularly for covered areas, you'll want a radiant electric or natural gas heater.  For comparison sake, let's look at a natural gas radiant patio heater.  Sunpak makes a good one, that uses 34,000 BTU per hour, and heats a 12x12 area.  It's much more efficient because the radiant heat is being directed, rather than just going out in all directions.  So now we're talking about a cost of roughly $.60 per hour to heat the same area.  You could also go electric, a typical 6,000 watt heater will heat something like 11 x 11, and cost would be in the $.75 per hour range.  Electric heaters also have a significantly lower installation cost.  You don't have to run gas, but you will have to run 240V power for most of them.  This makes a more economical option for larger areas, if you have a 10 x 20 covered patio for instance, two of those electric heaters will cover the entire area effectively. 


So why buy a firepit then?  Because sitting around an electric radiant heater might feel nice, but you get none of the atmosphere of the flame.  You want that gathering point, the mood of sitting around a fire.  So by all means buy one, they're really a lovely addition to the backyard.  Just be reasonable about the heating performance they can offer, and the cost-effectiveness they provide in those terms.  Of course we want to stay cozy, but we've got to keep that pocketbook in mind as well.

More from Fireplace Wizard

By The Wizard May 2, 2023
Are gas fireplaces good for emergency heat?
Hand Drawing of Fireplace Power Vent Routes
By The Wizard April 21, 2023
What do I do when I can't easily vent my fireplace? Is there a way? How does a power vent work, and what are the pros and cons of installing a fireplace with a fan assisted vent run?
Before and After of an old Gas Fireplace
By The Wizard April 20, 2023
What can you do to dress up or upgrade an existing gas fireplace? If the flame is too small, or you don't like the look of the brass trim and louvers, what can you do? Can you increase the size of the flame? Can you add a new face plate or brick liner?
hand drawn photo of a home with dollar signs coming out of the chimney.
By The Wizard March 18, 2023
Let's define value, and find out if a gas fireplace can increase the value of my home.
Hand Drawing of a Fireplace and Gas Valve
By The Wizard March 7, 2023
It's easy once you know how. So let's take a moment and learn how to turn on our gas fireplace, so we won't look dumb when we have guests over.
drawing of purchasing a fireplace online, from computer to warehouse to home.
By The Wizard February 28, 2023
I see so many cheap fireplaces online, is it a good idea to buy one? Are there any problems with buying a fireplace online? What's the right way to buy a fireplace?
Hand drawn diagram of a fireplace showing convection, conduction, and radiation.  Do I need a hearth
By The Wizard February 27, 2023
Safety first, and it looks good too.
Hand Drawing of a Pellet Stove parts, how to clean a pellet stove
By The Wizard February 25, 2023
Keep it clean folks, or you will regret it.
Hand drawing of removing a fireplace glass and screen
By The Wizard February 24, 2023
Fireplaces can be a bit intimidating, I know. But once you know how to get that glass off and give it a clean, you'll be very happy you took the time to learn. It's quick and easy, and makes a huge difference in the overall impression your fireplaces gives.
diagram of a vent-free gas fireplace, combustion byproducts of natural gas
By The Wizard February 22, 2023
There are some great reasons to use vent-free gas fireplaces, but there are also reasons to be cautious. Let's get some facts about ventless fireplaces, so that we can make our own decision.
More Posts
Share by: